Communist Party of Australia


The Guardian

Current Issue

PDF Archive

Web Archive


Press Fund


About Us

Why you should ...

CPA introduction

CPA Policies

CPA statements

Contact Us

facebook, twitter

Major Issues





Climate Change



What's On







Issue #1770      March 22, 2017

The radical spirit of Eleanor Marx

It is the biographer’s blessing (or curse) that the subject who once occupied every waking moment – and most dreams – never leaves you.

Eleanor Marx.

This International Women’s Day, Eleanor Marx was a strong presence in my thoughts. Eleanor’s socialist sisters of course founded this traditional celebration of the woman’s cause as International Working Women’s Day in 1911 in the United States, some years after her death.

It was a country whose abundant appeal, inequalities, and contradictions were well-known to the youngest daughter of Karl and mother of the Gasworkers’ Union even in the late 1880s.

And what ironies she would have observed in 2017. There is no greater symbol of the national myth of the modern US than the Statue of Liberty erected in 1886, witnessed by Eleanor Marx as she sailed into New York Harbour for the first time.

Famously, it is inscribed with the sonnet: “The New Colossus,” by Emma Lazarus, an American, descended like Eleanor, from migrant German Jews.

“Give me your tired, your poor,Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to meI lift my lamp beside the golden door.”

And yet the 45th president of the United States seems to have as much contempt for migrants, Muslims, and Mexicans as he does for women. An early and now infamous act of the new leader of the free world was the reinstatement of the “global gag order” banning US NGOs from offering abortion advice to women around the world.

Eleanor Marx campaigned, spoke, and wrote extensively about women’s reproductive rights and the necessity to reform the patriarchal family.

The symbolism of Donald Trump signing the executive order flanked by half a dozen men in grey suits will not be forgotten in a hurry, and is in marked contrast to the ranks of women active in the socialist and labour movements from the 19th century, on both sides of the Atlantic.

When you combine this with the president’s legendary proud and obscene misogyny and his having won the White House from a female favourite, it is surely enough to make even Lady Liberty weep.

But is the woman’s lot so much better closer to home and even under Britain’s second female prime minister? This year’s International Women’s Day was the date selected for the delivery of the Budget.

Theresa May is a Conservative committed to capitalism in its crudest, unreconstructed form. The Prime Minister sometimes opportunistically borrows the language of feminism, but she will always fail to deliver on what Eleanor understood in The Woman Question: From a Socialist Point of View, also published in 1886: “Truly the working woman approves the demand of the middle-class women’s movement… But only as means to the end that she may be fully armed for entering into the working-class struggle along with the man of her class… Her end and aim are not the right of free competition with men …”

The Woman Question was Eleanor Marx’s statement on the relationship between feminism and socialism in which she aimed to show how one was an integral necessity and not just an aspect of the other.

It is a manifesto as significant as, and more practically programmatic, than The Communist Manifesto, written many years earlier by her father and her “uncle” Engels.

As Eleanor had learned from Engels’ own superb radical feminist study, The Origin of Private Property, Family, and the State, and August Bebel’s Women and Socialism, sexual inequality is as much a question of economics as it is of biology and the social organisation of societies.

May’s promotion of professional Tory women in her Cabinet and her lip service to the need for the fair play of equal pay, cannot begin to compensate in reality for the millions of working women made poorer in real terms by her policies of drastic austerity, hard Brexit, and the destruction of our National Health Service and social services.

The Woman Question was published on the eve of the founding of the Second International in Paris, where both Eleanor Marx and Clara Zetkin took the main platform to speak on women and labour.

Zetkin, the “Grandmother of German Communism,” was one of the original proposers and organisers of International Working Women’s Day.

In 1932, as the oldest member of the Reichstag, tradition required that she open the parliamentary session – which she did with a 40-minute counterblast against Hitler and the Nazi Party.

Nearly a century ago, women like Eleanor Marx, Clara Zetkin, and Rosa Luxemburg occupied the public sphere and claimed political power and authority equal to their male compatriots.

Today, figures like Trump and Putin represent an attempt to reclaim male mastery with excessively masculine, patriarchal, and long-ago bankrupt values that not only seek to silence women and drive us from the public sphere, but sanction the worst forms of trolling and hate speech, given the unregulated platforms of social media.

How would Eleanor and her sisters have responded to this new attempt to intimidate and muzzle working women and their advocates in 2017?

Not with silence but with greater and louder solidarity, as was her rallying call at the first May Day gathering in Hyde Park in 1890, when campaigning not against zero-hours contracts but for the eight-hour working day:

“We aim at a time when there will no longer be one class supporting two others, but the unemployed both at the top and bottom of society will be got rid of. This is not the end but only the beginning of the struggle … we must speak for the cause daily, and make the men, and especially the women that we meet, come into the ranks to help us.”

Rachel Holmes is the author of Eleanor Marx: A Life, from Bloomsbury Publishing

Morning Star

Next article – Murdered – Berta Cáceres

Back to index page

Go to What's On Go to Shop at CPA Go to Australian Marxist Review Go to Join the CPA Go to Subscribe to the Guardian Go to the CPA Maritime Branch website Go to the Resources section of our web site Go to the PDF of the Hot Earth booklet go to the World Federation of Trade Unions web site go to the Solidnet  web site Go to Find out more about the CPA