The Guardian • Issue #1973


Working class over-policed, while the rich enjoy freedom

  • The Guardian
  • Issue #1973

The response to the pandemic from Australian governments has revealed (perhaps more than any other event in recent history) their contempt for the Australian working class. This time, it manifested in the sharp difference between the policing of Western and Eastern Sydney.

Last week, the Australian Defence Force (ADF) deployed 300 personnel into Western Sydney for a COVID-19 suppression effort. Before the ADF’s deployment, the eight Sydney LGAs were already heavily policed in stark contrast to their Eastern counterparts.

Photos and video footage captured by citizens and shared across social media have shown how tens of police vehicles and groups of police officers have patrolled the streets of Western Sydney. However, in the east, people have enjoyed relaxed conditions, with public spaces overcrowded as they exercised or queued up for coffee at cafés.

In an attempt to ease fears, NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller stated that the operation is “centred around the welfare of the community and ensuring that stay-at-home orders […] are observed.”

Supporting Fuller’s claim, Brigadier Mick Garraway, who heads the ADF during the deployment, assured that military the presence will be “supporting in nature.”

ALP MP Tony Burke spoke out against the deployment, stating that “there was inadequate consultation with community leaders in those eight LGAs” and that “[p]eople felt that they were in some way being not trusted. They were conscious that the government said ‘don’t lock down Bondi’ but then sent the troops in on Western Sydney.”

Greens Senator Lidia Thorpe also criticised the move, stating: “Mobilising the police and Australian Defence Force to treat a public health crisis is absurd […]. Officers of the law are not experts in public health messaging, culturally accessible information and welfare support services that enable people to stay at home safely […].”

This is not the first time that working-class areas have been over-policed during the pandemic. Last year, the lockdown of North Melbourne and Flemington public housing was found to be “not based on direct health advice and violated Victorian human rights laws,” according to the Victorian ombudsman. Much like the military rollout in Western Sydney, residents in these communities were not consulted, leaving many without their medicines and food for more than a week. This contrasted against the response at a complex in Melbourne’s Southbank, where two COVID-19 cases were found, with police less present.

If the military truly wanted to play a supportive role, they wouldn’t be roaming the streets of Western Sydney. Instead, they could be building quarantine centres or administering vaccinations through their medical staff.

However, NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian isn’t interested in truly supporting the working class. Her voters aren’t out there. It is easier for her government to make an example out of Western Sydney, pretending to be tough with the pandemic because those communities are so heavily othered.

Tags COVID-19
The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More