The Guardian • Issue #2105

The sham of the Ukraine ‘Peace’ Summit

A woman covers her son with a blanket after fleeing the war from neighbouring Ukraine at the border crossing in Medyka, southeastern Poland.

A woman covers her son with a blanket after fleeing the war from neighbouring Ukraine at the border crossing in Medyka, southeastern Poland. Photo: AP Sergei Grits flickr.com (CC BY 2.0 Deed)

The much-vaunted Ukraine Peace Summit in Switzerland came and went. The world media reminded us almost daily of the unanimity of support, of the depth of feeling and of the huge number of participant countries. We were told of Russia’s intransigence and of the significance of China’s refusal to attend. It was designed as a global show of force and of solidarity in support for Zelensky and the US/NATO-inspired and resourced war.

A hundred states attended. A communiqué was signed. Russia was denounced. China was criticised. But the end result revealed some splits in the global community.

The final communiqué was eventually signed by 78 countries as well as the EU. There had been talk that as many as 120 nations would participate. A significant minority  not sign. No BRICS-member state was a signatory.

American President Biden was criticised by Ukrainian leader Zelensky for not attending. He had been in Europe in early June to attend the D-Day anniversary in France. He returned to Italy to attend the G7 meeting that was held between 13 - 15 June. More than a few eyebrows were raised when he failed to find time to go to Switzerland on the following day.

The whole affair was something of an anti-climax. To achieve consensus, 10 points from the ‘peace plan’ were whittled down to just three. These were nuclear safety, food security, and a return of prisoners of war held by Russia. No actual reference was made to the war.

Zelensky, in his opening remarks made the claim that “I believe that we will witness history being made here.” The final document included a vague call for future meetings with no dates attached.

As a propaganda-fest, it might have had its moments, but has left no visible mark.

Russia was not invited. Even so, President Putin reiterated his desire to see an end to the conflict. In this, he has firm that there are non-negotiables for Russia. The four regions now regarded as being part of Russia must remain in Russian hands, and Ukraine must refrain from seeking NATO membership. The US and its coterie of supporters see this as blind aggression. Ukraine refuses to shift from its position regarding negotiations with Russia. Russia, in the Ukrainian scenario must completely withdraw from all those territories. These demands are seen in the West as being positive.

China, for its part, chose not to attend the conference. It has already proposed a path to negotiations, which has been bluntly rejected.

Beijing’s Global Times has written that while China is not a party to the crisis, it “has been doing its utmost to promote peace talks. From the document entitled ‘China’s Position on the Political Settlement of the Ukraine Crisis’ to the ‘six-point consensus,’ China’s position has been consistent … . Who is creating divisions and who is bridging them?”

It is a fair question.

What once was a seemingly unbreakable chain of pro-Ukrainian, anti-Russian sentiment is looking  shaky. The conference failed to secure any significant support from the global south. Many observers have made the point that the highly partisan nature of the conference was being viewed as a means to push Russia into a corner. The result was a rift between the West and non-Western nations. This, in turn, is being seen as a failure of policy for the USA and its NATO allies as the world splits into more and more irreconcilable camps.

The USA and NATO are pouring more and more weaponry into their war with Russia. Ukrainian armed forces are being given the green light to use these weapons against Russia and to strike more and more deeply into Russian territory.

The US has stated that more Patriot missiles, that are “rolling off the production line” will be directed away from existing ‘customers’ in favour of Ukraine. US national security spokesperson, John Kirby has made it plain that this would in no way disrupt shipments to either Israel or the Chinese island Taiwan.

Putin, speaking in Vietnam after leaving the DPRK, made it clear that he regarded arming Ukraine as a hostile act. South Korea has declared its intention to boost its arms shipments to Ukraine.

The situation grows more dangerous. Peace summits are a good idea in general, but serious attempts to resolve the war are needed, not propaganda offensives by Zelensky on behalf of his US and NATO paymasters.

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More