- The Guardian
- Issue #2114
After considerable campaigning by climate scientists and environmentalists Google took an important step by demonetising the Heartland Institute by removing paid ads. Youtube is a major source of climate disinformation. The battle has not been won. The Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) recently discovered that Google is still allowing climate disinformation to be monetised.
“The climate crisis is one of the greatest threats that humanity faces, which is why the fossil fuel companies that oppose climate action are dead-set on obscuring the threats and their causes,” the UCS Scientists said.
Climate denial on YouTube has evolved radically in recent years, posing a fresh challenge to those seeking public support for climate action. The impact is considerable among young people, researchers from the Centre for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH) found in a survey in the US.
Alarmingly, CCDH found a third of teens in the US believe climate policies “cause more harm than good” and 30 per cent said, “climate science and the climate movement can’t be trusted.”
The “Old Denial” centred on two key false narratives, which have both declined in use:
“Global warming is not happening” – which is down from 48 per cent of all denial claims in 2018 to 14 per cent in 2023.
“Humans are not causing global warming and climate change” – down from 17 per cent to 16 per cent.
“New Denial” has evolved to focus on three increasingly prevalent narratives:
“Climate solutions won’t work” – up from 9 per cent to 30 per cent.
“Climate science and the climate movement are unreliable” – up from 23 per cent to 35 per cent.
“The impacts of global warming are beneficial or harmless” – up from 4 per cent to 6 per cent.
“New Denial” narratives – which constituted 35 per cent of all climate denial on YouTube in 2018 – now represent the large majority (70 per cent). In the same period, the share of “Old Denial” has dropped from 65 per cent to just 30 per cent of total claims.
The UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change provided a stark warning of the consequences of failing to act on climate change, while describing the “growth in misinformation” as an attempt “to maintain the status quo by actors in positions of power.”
“Misinformation on platforms such as Google and YouTube poses a legitimate threat to our nation’s ability to respond to this crisis, as well as putting climate scientists in peril through direct threats and causing global harm as people die in extreme weather events,” UCS said.
The climate crisis intensifies each and every day. There’s little time to waste. The recent UN Environmental Programme Emissions Gap Report has sounded the alarm; we are currently heading towards a dangerous 2.8°C global warming, far exceeding the Paris Agreement’s 1.5°C target. As pointed out by Barbados Prime Minister Mia Mottley at COP26, even a 2°C increase spells disaster for vulnerable communities.
As humanity stands on the brink of a climate catastrophe, vested economic and political interests continue to foster and fund climate mis/disinformation. Addressing climate mis/disinformation is a prerequisite to effectively fighting climate change. The recent Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report highlighted the necessity of immediate action, noting that organised dissemination of scientifically inaccurate information has exacerbated polarisation and hindered the formulation of new and ambitious climate policies.
Opinion in Australia appears to be better, but there is no room for complacency. Just 60 per cent of Australians accept that climate disruption is human-caused, a fall of six percentage points from the previous poll 18 months earlier and well behind the global average of 73 per cent according to the results from French polling company Elabe.
Keep an eye out for mis/disinformation, counter it, call on the provider to take it down and tell others to do likewise.
