The Guardian • Issue #2126

Woolies’ warehouse workers commence indefinite strike

Afternoon shift members at EPDC in Sydney brave the rain to endorse strike action on 12 November.

Afternoon shift members at EPDC in Sydney brave the rain to endorse strike action on 12 November.

On Thursday 21 November members of the United Workers’ Union (UWU) at four Woolworths distribution centres commenced an indefinite strike against their employer. Workers at Melbourne Liquor, Melbourne South Regional, Wodonga Regional, and Erskine Park (NSW) Distribution Centres began pickets at their respective worksites while workers at Heathwood Chilled and Fresh Distribution Centre (Qld) undertook a one-hour stoppage to endorse an indefinite strike alongside their colleagues.

They are joined by workers at the third-party logistics company Lineage in Melbourne, who move frozen goods for Woolworths, commencing a strike of their own on 22 Friday.

The combined strike of these warehouses represents a significant challenge for Woolworths, who have not faced a multiple warehouse strike in recent memory, and their response has been to stand down workers at the striking warehouses. This involves standing down without pay all workers, regardless of whether they are union members or not, and ceasing operations at the affected sites.

On Tuesday 12 November UWU members had undertaken one-hour stoppages at four Woolworths distribution centres in Victoria and NSW in order to endorse an indefinite strike in the leadup to the busy Christmas period. While Primary Connect has 16 distribution centres, the Christmas period places a significant strain on its network under normal circumstances and the workers hope to use the busy period to amplify the effect of multiple warehouses striking in order to force the company to meet their demands.

Workers at these distribution centres have been bargaining with their employer Primary Connect (the logistics arm of Woolworths Group) over the second half of 2024 with little progress in reaching a new Enterprise Bargaining Agreement (EBA).

While the workers are demanding significant pay rises to account for several years of high inflation and cost of living pressures, along with a series of other working conditions, a major conflict that has developed in bargaining. It is in regards to the program of a performance framework and engineered standards that Primary Connect is insistent on introducing at all its warehouses nationwide.

With the advent of computerised warehousing and warehouse management software, almost all actions taken by workers in a warehouse are confirmed and logged via equipment like computer terminals, scanners, or voice headsets. Primary Connect contracts specialist firms to observe and time workers throughout their warehouses in order to create an average time it should take the ‘reasonable worker’ to complete each task in the warehouse.

Then throughout their shifts workers are presented with a ‘goal time’ that the system believes the job can be completed in and when finishing their shifts they are presented with a performance percentage between 1 and 100 depending on how the system considers them to have performed against their goal times.

While the measuring of performance is not new, what is new is Primary Connect’s attempts to introduce a performance framework at all its warehouses that requires workers to maintain an average performance of 100 per cent. Failure to maintain this level of performance under the framework would allow the company to discipline the worker, ranging from close monitoring and coaching to improve performance, warnings, and all the way up to termination.

Primary Connect attempted to introduce the framework earlier this year but significant resistance organised by the UWU led to them suspending the program and withdrawing disciplinary warnings that had been issued under the framework.

One of the union’s claims in bargaining is for EBA clauses that expressly prevent the company disciplining any worker on the basis of performance, similar to existing clauses in other agreements, while Primary Connect has thus far refused to even consider the claim and retorted that the re-introduction of the framework is a non-negotiable position for them.

It is the union’s contention that the framework is inherently unethical and unsafe as it forces workers to pursue a performance target while failing to consider the myriad of factors that influence a warehouse worker at any one time or the natural variation in ability between workers or even the variation in ability a worker experiences from shift to shift.

The company faces the prospect of significant shortages and delays in a very busy part of the year as these warehouses combined move millions of cartons per week under normal circumstances. Even before Primary Connect faced the prospect of a strike its performance framework was already gathering media attention from print and television outlets, with a consistent theme of its unreasonableness and now the news of a strike has sent Woolworths’ share price tumbling to a four-year low.

In addition, this strike campaign adds more negative public attention on top of Woolworth’s increasingly poor public image. In a year of significant public attention and criticism for price gouging, price collusion, and Australian Competition and Consumer Commission investigations, these warehouse workers can expect a decent amount of public sympathy in their strike and fight against the framework.

While the struggle of these workers is of course a struggle between them and their employer in the most immediate sense, it also is part of a broader struggle against a campaign by capitalists to introduce monitoring and disciplinary regimes, so called ‘scientific management,’ that breaks a worker’s job into a series of discrete tasks with an ‘optimal’ execution that can be timed and averaged to create a standard that workers must meet or be punished.

As Marx once wrote, under capitalism the worker is reduced to little more than an extension of the machine and under these systems the worker’s very physical movement is controlled and monitored in order to maximise the extraction of surplus value and therefore maximise the potential profits of a capitalist enterprise.

As capitalists experience a never-ending need to seek profit and further exploit the resources available to them systems like the performance framework are a reality that awaits many workers whenever the technology that enables them is adopted in an industry. We should support these warehouse workers not only because it is another battle between the working and capitalist classes but because it is also a front in the fight against cruel management systems like the performance framework.

All support to the Woolies’ workers in their strike!

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More