The Guardian • Issue #2130

The ceasefire: hopes and aspirations must be fought for

Rally for Palestine / Boorloo, Sunday 27th October 2024.

Rally for Palestine / Boorloo, Sunday 27th October 2024.

There were images of intense jubilation on what were once the streets of Gaza when news first emerged that a ceasefire in Gaza might be a reality. That sense of euphoria came before the dawning of a new day and the enormity of the tasks ahead could be considered. The world has watched and wept as the carnage has unfolded. They hope the shelling, the bombing, the genocide might be at an end. The fears, the hatreds, the driving sense of wrong, will live with the people for a very long time to come.

The pause, as part of a staged end of hostilities in Gaza, is welcome, if long overdue. Too many people have died. Too many have been maimed, too many have been driven to despair. The peace, if peace it will be, will be a tenuous affair. But will that period of calm be sustained? Massive questions need to be asked. Those questions all boil down to one burning overarching question; what happens next?

At best it is a temporary 6-week pause in Israel’s bombardments. Israel is not withdrawing from Gaza. It is telling the people to return to the major cities as if their homes will be there waiting for them. Is this yet another ploy to round them up for more mass bombings?

Another issue that will dominate the thoughts of many will be whether or not the war criminals responsible for the genocide, and the deliberate policy of withholding food as a weapon will be brought to justice. That is unlikely, given the level of support that is offered by the USA and its closest allies including Australia. But there are other pressing concerns.

If the ceasefire were to hold and if ‘peace’ return, then there are enormous obstacles to overcome. It has been conservatively estimated that reconstruction costs could be as high as $40 billion. Two-thirds of all structures in Gaza have been destroyed or damaged. There are 50 million tonnes of rubble to be removed. According to the UN Environment Protection Programme, this could take up to 15 years to accomplish.

While Gaza remains a disputed territory and one without continuous and stable governance, then investors will be chary about risking money. Capital requires a return and it will be capitalism that will seek to profit from any rebuilding program. The post WW2 Marshall Plan attests to that.

The future is precarious. The Palestinian people might not be thinking too far into that future. The immediate prospects of an end to the killing will be, for most, enough. Getting sufficient aid is next. Healing the physical wounds is now possible. Healing the psychological wounds is all but impossible.

The people, Palestinian and Israeli alike, cannot simply exist in an uncertain world, waiting for the next round of atrocity, of massacre, of bloodletting. The working people of both societies deserve so much better. Those who ensure that uncertainty hangs over the people need to be removed.

Peace must be more than simply the absence of war. As the negotiations for a pause in the destruction were being finalised, two statements were issued that deserve attention. One was from the Palestinian People’s Party (PPP), the vanguard communist party in Palestine and the other came from the Communist Party of Israel CPI).

In its statement, the PPP stressed that “stopping the genocide and destruction and ensuring the return of the displaced to their homes, in addition to the flow of aid to our people throughout Gaza, the release of thousands of prisoners and the withdrawal of the occupation forces from the Gaza, is a vital and necessary matter for our people. It necessitates the unity of all its forces and factions in order to ensure the implementation of the agreement and the achievement of these goals. This is also essential to prevent the occupation from evading the obligations of the agreement as is its permanent habit, and from its persistence in aborting the aspirations of our people.”

The PPP’s statement calls for unity of all “factions” engaged in the struggle. This is important. There has been a tendency to view the anti-genocide movement as being a campaign by Hamas alone. It tends to legitimise Hamas as the voice of Gaza and almost by default, the voice of Palestinian resistance.

It is with this in mind that the call by the Palestinian Party to “quickly unify the Palestinian political stance within the framework of the Palestine Liberation Organization” becomes important.

There is an immediate and pressing need to get aid to the people, to provide food, shelter and medical care and to begin the task of rebuilding. Without political resolve and without a clear program for the future, this will become a temporary measure as a prelude to a new wave of aggression. The Palestinian people are engaged in a national liberation struggle against Israel but also against the weight of monopoly capital and imperialism that threatens peace everywhere.

The statement from the ICP reflects a common accord with the aspirations of their Palestinian comrades. It, too, welcomes the agreement that will “bring everyone home – prisoners, abductees, detainees and hostages, Israelis and Palestinians alike.” It continues, saying that “we are not satisfied with just the agreement reached and will continue to fight for progress toward serious negotiations that will lead to the end of the occupation and the siege, and lead to a just and comprehensive peace, based on recognising the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination and the establishment of its independent state alongside the State of Israel.”

The Israeli Party declared that “we see the reconstruction of the Gaza Strip as an urgent task and call on the world to bear this responsibility, and to prevent the right-wing government in Israel from using the remaining time to complete the implementation of the agreement to continue with genocidal crimes or to resume them after the completion of the prisoners exchange deal.”

The struggle of the Palestinian people is not confined to Gaza. The atrocities committed by the Netanyahu regime have also wreaked havoc on the West Bank. There are persistent calls by extremist settler groups, backed by the far right in the Knesset, to annex the West Bank and all of Palestine in order to create a ‘Greater Israel.’ The biblical referencing has little to do with any religious belief or interpretation on the part of the political right. Their real interests are more aligned with political intrigues, self-serving and the broader interests of US imperialism that seeks a greater Israel as a geopolitical stronghold in the region.

There is an objective necessity to unite those forces within Israel and Palestine who recognise that peace must be established and that it must be a lasting peace. A state for the Palestinian people must become a reality. The PPP recognise this. The ICP recognise this. The Palestinian Authority, the UN, the majority of states all recognise this to be the only rational way forward.

Those who call for a one-state solution need to remain clear-headed. A united secular state is possible but not before a socialist transformation of both Israel and Palestine has been achieved. The national liberation struggle of the Palestinian people is one significant step along the way. It would deal a blow to the aspirations of imperialism who require a divided and dislocated people. Two states, co-existing, might not be the best of all possible worlds but is worth striving for.

Solidarity actions in support Palestinians must continue.

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More