The Guardian • Issue #2137

Medicare: PEOPLE FIRST

  • The Guardian
  • Issue #2137

Photo: Anna Pha

Health care is a basic human right. The original concept behind Medicare was a national health insurance scheme that offered universal access to free medical services through a system of bulk billing whereby patients were not required to pay an upfront fee for service. Access to public hospitals was also free and access universal.

The potential of Medicare and the public hospital system has not been realised. Instead there has been deterioration in many areas. Public hospitals are short of staff, resources and beds. There are shortages of GPs and specialists, as well as huge distortions in the geographic distribution of services, with oversupply in some areas, and none in others.

The public hospital system has been run down, starved of the necessary funds and resources, resulting in long waiting lists and enormous pressures on staff. Governments cry poor as billions of dollars are siphoned off to subsidise private hospitals through the private health insurance. Without the more than $8 billion a year in federal government subsidies that the private hospital system receives, it would collapse overnight.

A combination of long waiting lists, scare tactics and tax incentives have seen an increase in the take up of private health insurance. This has resulted in the emergence of a two-tiered health system, with queue jumping by private patients in public hospitals and immediate access guaranteed in private hospitals.

The refusal by successive governments to increase the pay of GPs through Medicare has seen bulk billing diminish to vanishing point: It is now common for patients to be left with a co-payment of $50 or more.

Nursing homes are chronically understaffed, and many of the staff under-qualified. GP shortages and a lack of doctors prepared to bulk bill place additional pressures on public hospitals. Some rural and remote areas are without GPs. The lack of provision of suitable Indigenous health services is nothing short of  criminal.

For mental health, primary health care services are either unaffordable or lacking. The community care programs that were supposed to support people with mental health conditions when de-institutionalisation took place are totally inadequate.

HEALTH CARE REFORM

Reforms are needed. The question is in which direction: public or private, free or fee-for service, people first or profits first? The health care debate between the two major parties is about how to privatise the system, dressed up in terms of choice and competition, who is bulk-billed, what additional services are provided.

But the crisis facing the public health system does not arise out of the public nature of the system. It is the promotion of and diversion from public funds to the private, for-profit sector that has resulted in the present untenable situation.

This process has been a conscious one on the part of successive governments of both major parties, all intent on privatising health care. In this scenario Medicare is broken up and handed over to private health insurance funds to manage. Public hospitals will be funded by fees for services from the health insurance funds, not directly by government. They will be competing on a health market, with increased pressure to churn through patients as quickly and cheaply as possible, regardless of consequences to their care.

Private health funds will offer, as they do now, a range of plans for hospital cover in the private system. This cover will be extended to buy places in public hospitals and access to medical services, an area that the private sector has been lobbying to cover for years. Those who can afford it will be able to buy health and hospital plans that offer a more complete range of services, that cover the gap between the standard refund and what a private provider charges. There will be no lid on what private practitioners charge.

This will create possibly three instead of two tiers of health care – the safety net,  those who can afford full cover and jump waiting lists and possibly a third group of people who fail to qualify for the safety net but do not have the means for extended private cover.

Welcome to a US-style managed health care system in which health funds will be telling you what medical procedures you can have and in which hospital! So much for the private system’s much vaunted “choice”.

Costs will skyrocket while the transnational corporations taking over the health system will be rolling in profits.

THE PUBLIC ALTERNATIVE

The alternative is a fully-fledged public health system, with the government paying doctors and funding public hospitals and other health services provided free on a universal basis. Such a system, with the elimination of the profit motive and layers of administration, is the only one capable of delivering quality health care to everyone and would cost less than is being spent now.

If these issues were addressed and preventative and community health care improved, then many of the conditions that lead to hospitalisation could be avoided.

The debate is on. It needs to be redirected to the key issue of public or private, for people or for profits. The opportunities are there to join in – talk-back radio, newspapers, on the PM’s blog, at union meetings, in community organisations, social media, or even at the bus stop.

The Communist Party of Australia is calling for major reforms to the health and community care services in Australia. These should be based around the following principles:

  • universal access – regardless of income or locality
  • free services at the point of delivery
  • services to be of the highest quality
  • services funded through central taxation revenue
  • services provided by the public sector
  • planned system of training, staffing and provision of services

Funding and planning are critical. The economic crisis does not preclude finding the necessary funds to build a public health system on the above principles. The present under-funding is ideologically based and a matter of lack of political will.

The private health insurance rebate should be abolished. This would free up more than $8 billion to provide a quality health care program.

Funding to public hospitals must be increased as a matter of urgency. As an initial step, while rebuilding the public hospital system, private hospitals would be directly subsidised for private patients at $300 a night per patient. This would be phased out over several years.

The question of how doctors are paid needs reviewing, with a focus on components for salary and other costs to replace the present focus on payment per patient consultation. Funding per visit through Medicare rebates has led to rapid churning of patients in some practices, and made it more difficult for doctors to give the time needed and for the elderly and chronically ill, in particular, to receive the attention they need.

Dental health should become an integral part of Medicare.

Aged care should be taken out of the hands of the private sector and philanthropists.

Measures are needed to overcome the shortages of qualified nurses, GPs, medical specialists, aged care, and other health professionals. This needs planning in conjunction with universities and other training institutions. It cannot be left to ‘the market’ any longer. Substantial increases in funding are required for preventative health care and community care services, for Indigenous health programs, for aged care, mental health, and rural and remote areas.

These goals can only be achieved through planning and coordination by the public sector. The development and provision of services needs community involvement.

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More