The Guardian • Issue #2139

Canada’s CSIS takes Trump’s invasion threats seriously

Map of Canada/US

Graphic: TUBS – Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

President Donald Trump’s threats to invade Canada have been taken very seriously by former senior Canadian intelligence officials, who said that the US is covertly destabilising Canada.  Ward Elcock, former head of CSIS (Canadian Security Intelligence Service) and national security adviser, said Trump, “intends clearly to try and destabilise our economy.” He also regards Musk “as a problem” on a number of fronts. South African-born Elon Musk is a Canadian citizen. Musk tweeted on X that “Canada is not a real country.”

Dick Fadden, former head of CSIS and a national security adviser to former PM Stephen Harper, says the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) will use Musk’s X platform to try and change political views. “If so, that’s foreign interference.” Fadden says it is possible that the US government would use more intrusive tactics, such as financing pro-annexationist groups within Canada. The CIA has “an extraordinary capacity to do this.”

Neil Bisson, a former CSIS intelligence officer who is now director of the Global Intelligence Knowledge Network, says that there are some Canadians who are vulnerable to anti-Canadian propaganda, particularly the young who feel economically disenfranchised. He told CBC News: “If you have individuals who are concerned about where their next meal is coming from or if they’re going to get a roof over their head, that supersedes sovereignty.”

US political analyst, Malcolm Nance, also takes Trump’s threats seriously. He was an intelligence and foreign policy analyst, a former CIA agent, and was a visiting lecturer on counter-​terrorism at Macquarie University’s Centre on Policing, Intelligence and Counter-terrorism. He believes that over the next 6 to 18 months Trump will politically and economically destabilise Canada leading up to a possible military invasion. Trump’s plan is to split political parties with secret destabilisation plans.

President Trump’s threats to invade Canada have been taken very seriously by US politicians. So much so that Rep. Seth Magaziner has introduced the No Invading Allies Act legislation into Congress to prohibit Trump from invading Canada and other friendly nations. The bill will ban the use of federal funds for a military invasion.

Since his inauguration Trump has continuously attacked Canada. He referred to PM Justin Trudeau as the “Governor of the 51st State,” seeing him as weak. Mark Carney replaced Trudeau as Liberal prime minister on 9 March. Carney is seen as a much tougher negotiator. Trump has repeatedly insulted Canada in virtually every discussion he has had on the subject, saying with his usual mixture of threat, falsehood and exaggeration that  if Canada became the 51st state it would have “lower taxes, and far better military protection for the people of Canada – and no tariffs.” In early February Trump stated that “Canada was not viable” as a country, and that “Canada would not exist without the United States.” Forty-eight hours later, he imposed 25 per cent tariffs on Canada. He claims that the “vast majority” of Canadian youth want to join the US.

A recent poll from Angus Reid found only 10 per cent of Canadians, and 21 per cent of Conservatives, would vote to join the US, depending on the conditions offered. Even French-speaking Quebec, with its history of wanting secession, saw no advantage in becoming a US state. The reality is that the average Canadian has far better conditions than US citizens, with free hospitals, great health care, and low crime rates. Canadians will fight against any US invasion.

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More