The Guardian • Issue #2158

The need for a Palestinian state

Paletine and CPA flags at a rally.

In Gaza the glaring moral and legal question is why the ‘international community’ has gone to so much effort to protect the aggressor, preserve Israel’s occupation, and deny the victims any means to defend themselves? If they do not want Palestinians to resist, why do they not themselves confront the aggressor and force an end to the occupation, the siege and dispossession?

When the defenceless population in Gaza was under attack from the region’s most powerful military, all calls were to prevent the victims from defending themselves. Meanwhile, endless supplies of sophisticated weaponry were sent to the occupier despite its already massive dominance and indiscriminate and criminal attacks on civilians.

It is necessary to see conflict’s root causes in historical context to see the necessity of a Palestinian state.

When Palestinians started their first unarmed uprising in 1987, 40 years after their expulsion from their homes and 20 years after the brutal occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip began, they had no rockets; they had only stones to confront heavily armed occupation forces: they had no state apparatus.

Hamas, as a resistance movement, was born in 1988. Israel, desperate to break the political monopoly of the Palestine Liberation Organisation as the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people, tacitly allowed Hamas to flourish.

Before any Palestinian fired a single shot at the start of the second uprising, in September 2000, Israel had already gunned down dozens of unarmed demonstrators. Palestinians learned these lessons well: Israel will meet any peaceful challenge with lethal force, so one had better be prepared to fight back.

We need to recall these facts to understand the situation without the misrepresentations that serve the US and Israel’s interests. The starting point of history is chosen not from the origins of the problem, but from whatever point suits the narrative of the powerful which thrives on division and chaos.

It is a tactic of the perpetrators of the genocide to portray this crime as a “war,” which implies a clash between two sides. In fact it is a campaign of extermination against an unarmed civilian population.

Recognition is an important precursor to a negotiated lasting peace settlement which can only be negotiated by two states – Israel and Palestine.

At present some three million or more Palestinians are living under Israeli military occupation. They are illegally denied sovereignty and independence. The symbolic and political nature of recognition is important.

The US blocked the UN Security Council from moving forward on a Palestinian bid to be recognised as a full member state at the UN last year. At the time 12 nations, including Australia, supported the resolution. Britain and Switzerland abstained, and the US exercised its right to veto the resolution.

Professor Shahram Akbarzadeh, director of the Middle East Studies Forum at Deakin University, notes that Australia recognising a Palestinian state would send a strong message to the United States that the “global dynamic is changing.”

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More