The Guardian • Issue #2159

Trump’s culture wars

Rally for science.

Photo: rawpixel.com (CC0)

On 27 March 2025 President Donald Trump issued executive order Restoring Truth And Sanity To American History attacking the “widespread effort to rewrite our Nation’s history, replacing objective facts with a distorted narrative driven by ideology rather than truth.” To stop what Trump saw as ‘corrosive ideology,’ his administration has set about undermining the institutions based on cultural and scientific knowledge. It was ordered by a president who has neither a scientific nor a history academic background.

Trump’s administration is attacking any institution that receives federal funding for their stand on Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives. This includes targeting colleges and universities for flouting the president’s priorities, including universities that allow transgender athletes to compete in women’s sports. These attacks have been carried out by Trump with barely a whimper of dissent from his administration or the Republican Party.

Trump’s 14 March executive order allowed him to gut the federal Institute of Museum and Library Services, which works to “advance, support, and empower America’s museums, libraries, and related organisations.” In 2024 the agency provided US$266 million in grants to American cultural institutions. Trump withheld US$30 million ($AUD46 million).

In April, the National Endowment for the Humanities cut millions of dollars in grant funding, affecting thousands of organisations. In response the Oregon Humanities and the Federation of State Humanities Councils issued a lawsuit, alleging the cuts were an “attempted destruction, spearheaded by DOGE.” In July the Senate and the House approved the Trump administration’s request to cut US$1.1 billion in funding from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, NPR and PBS.

In August, the White House ordered an extensive review of the Smithsonian’s twenty-one museums in advance of next year’s 250th anniversary of the United States. This institution is one of the finest in the world. The attack is based solely on President Trump’s interpretation of US history. In a letter to the Smithsonian Institution Secretary, Lonnie Bunch III, the White House laid out in detail the steps it expects how the institution will focus on “Americanism.” The federal government will review the Smithsonian’s social media, exhibition text and educational materials, to “assess tone, historical framing, and alignment with American ideals.” The Smithsonian must remove “divisive or partisan narratives, and restore confidence in our shared cultural institutions.” The Smithsonian has denied these allegations and so far has not removed exhibits, despite the pressure to do so.

The Congressional Black Caucus, has described the Trump administration of ‘whitewashing our nation’s history.’ The administration is accusing the National Museum of African American History and Culture of “distorting our nation’s history.” The caucus said the Trump Administration is erasing and retelling Black history.

Trump’s attack on famous universities, such as Harvard University and other Ivy League institutions, has damaged America’s standing as a centre of non-politicised knowledge and science. Trump’s ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ raised taxes on university endowments, increasing from 1.4 per cent to a maximum of 21 per cent. Trump has also attempted to impose his approach on overseas institutions that receive US research funds. Because this is the US we’re talking about, the culture war doesn’t stop at the USA’s borders – Australian researchers have received a questionnaire asking them intrusive questions about diversity, equity, and inclusion.

Californian Democratic congressman, Ro Khanna, has argued that Vice President Vance fears universities: “Vance calls the university the enemy because he knows what lives here: historians, economists, law professors, and scientists who threaten him not with force, but with ideas.” This goes hand-in-hand with Republican attitudes. A 2024 Pew Research Center poll found that only 20 per cent of conservative Republican voters had a positive view of colleges’ impact.

Scientific institutions have not been immune to cuts, with the laying off of scientists who challenge his agenda. Trump ignores high-quality evidence and facts, to be replaced by the administration as arbiter of scientific truth, pushing out experts in federal agency leadership. He has wiped out funding for critical scientific research programmes within and outside the government. He has cut the public out of government decision-making processes and silenced independent advisory committees. His administration has spread disinformation, distorting scientific findings and halted government data collection. Trump’s Secretary of Heath, Robert F Kennedy Jr has cancelled $500 million with of funding for mRNA vaccine research.

In reaction, the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) is mobilising scientists to oppose rollbacks of environmental and public health protections, and has sued the administration.

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More