The Guardian • Issue #2180

EDITORIAL

What about it?

  • The Guardian
  • Issue #2180

People who support an ongoing genocide in Palestine have a problem. They want to support a campaign of dispossession and mass genocide, but still look like they care. They want to oppose demonstrators who are against Israel’s murderous campaign against Palestinian people, but they still want to feel like the good guys.

It’s just not a good look to come out and say that you’re in favour of mass murder. You might think this would leave Israel supporters with nothing to say to those who protest the genocide, but they manage. One way the pro-Israel crowd solve the problem is to ask a question: what about Sudan? What about Iran? What about (some other country that’s in the news)? Why aren’t you protesting about them?

This line of argument is called ‘whataboutery’ or ‘whataboutism.’ It’s also known as ‘changing the subject.’ In conversation it’s easily answered. I’m protesting for Palestine because I’m against mass murder and dispossession there, you’re changing the subject. If you really care about Sudan, why aren’t you protesting about it? People who practice whataboutery never care about the other country. It’s just a handy way to try to shut down criticism of Israel.

Another response to whataboutery is to explain our stake in the issue. Opposing genocide and dispossession is all the reason anyone needs to oppose Israel’s actions in Palestine, but you could always tell the whataboutery-user that whatever’s happening in other places, Australia has rolled out the red carpet for Israel’s president.

“What about?” distracts a lot of people from the simple facts of the situation: Israel is carrying out a genocide. Whataboutery becomes not just a distraction, but almost a weapon when it’s institutionalised. The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of anti-semitism includes a number of examples that label criticism of Israel as anti-semitic. One of them is “applying double standards by requiring of (Israel) a behaviour not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation.” This is an invitation to pro-Israel activists to use whataboutery as a reason for dismissing people from jobs, punishing the ABC or defunding universities. This is not exaggeration. Those are powers that the government’s ‘Anti-Semitism Envoy’ Jillian Segal has demanded.

The IHRA definition has been adopted by Australian universities and will definitely be used as an excuse to punish protesters. The Australian government has adopted the definition, probably to keep the pro-Israel lobby happy. There is an alternative, the Jerusalem Declaration on antisemitism, which does not engage in whataboutery or rule out criticism of Israel.

One thing that the “what about?” question does is ask why Israel is treated differently. The Israel supporters want to stop people criticising Israel’s genocide or Australia’s support for it, but it’s not a bad question. Israel gets massive support for its arms industry through generous contracts to the likes of Elbit Systems who have had $49.6 million of our money since October 2023. Australia is part of the supply chain for the F-35 jet fighters Israel uses to bomb Gaza. As everyone knows, Australia has just hosted the Israeli Head of State in the name of ‘unity.’ Israel is treated very differently and that should stop.

Next time you cop whataboutery, tell whoever’s practicing it that they should go demonstrate about other places if they care, and that you’ll keep turning up to protest Israel’s genocide and Australia’s support for it. All around the country that’s what the Communist Party of Australia will be doing.

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More