The Guardian • Issue #2205

Worth Streaming

Denial: David Irving vs Deborah Lipstadt

Denial: David Irving vs Deborah Lipstadt

Denial is directed by Mick Jackson, starring Rachel Weisz as Deborah Lipstadt, and Timothy Spall as David Irving. The film covers the 1996 - 2000 lawsuit of David Irving versus Penguin Books Ltd and Deborah Lipstadt, a US academic who called him a Holocaust denier and falsifier of history.

Lipstadt’s British legal team decides to examine Irving’s historical work to demonstrate he had manipulated the primary evidence. In court Irving presents himself as a respectable historian (he is untrained) but clearly manipulative. Denial shows the mechanism by which Irving’s reputation as a serious historian collapses.

Lipstadt is portrayed as passionate and outspoken. She gradually recognises that personally winning the historical argument is not the same thing as winning the court case. The strongest part of Lipstadt’s character arc is learning to trust the British legal system and her historical team. Deborah’s defence is to test Irving’s interpretation against the material evidence by going to the documents, buildings, photographs, demographic evidence and physical remains. The court case shows how a historical falsified argument can be dismantled through the critical examination of evidence.

The historical consultants’ work on Auschwitz was a major component of the actual trial. Tom Wilkinson’s Richard Rampton QC, the British libel lawyer, is calm, methodical and almost emotionally detached, dramatically contrasting Lipstadt’s approach. The scene in which he visits Auschwitz and studies the physical layout is effective because it illustrates the film’s underlying philosophy, that the claims of history can be tested against the material and documentary evidence.

The film presents Irving as someone who possesses genuine historical knowledge and knows how to use documents, but who selects and interprets evidence according to a predetermined ideological position. Denial effectively conveys the judge finding Irving had deliberately manipulated and distorted the historical evidence.

The film does not give Holocaust denial a platform. The Auschwitz sequences tell us emotionally what the historical evidence has already demonstrated intellectually. Irving attempts to transform history into an ideological weapon. His method is to take genuine historical material and reorganise its meaning.

Denial provides a warning: ideological commitment does not invalidate historical interpretation, but becomes dangerous when ideology determines what evidence is allowed to mean. Historical interpretation is never produced in a political vacuum, as institutions, ideologies and struggles over power influence aspects of the past. History is a struggle over who has the power to define historical interpretation.

In 2023 Irving became seriously ill and has been confined to his sickbed in failing health since 2025. The court case is described in Deborah Lipstadt’s History on Trial: My day in court with a Holocaust Denier (2005). Richard Evans’ Lying About Hitler (2001) describes Irving’s misuse of documents.

As a trained historian I found the film fascinating and well worth watching. Denial is being shown on SBS OnDemand.

The Guardian can also be viewed/downloaded in PDF format. View More