- by Graham Holton
- The Guardian
- Issue #2173
Australia's first fully automated, around-the-clock, synthetic fuels research facility. CSIRO Perth, 2010. Photo: Darryl Peroni/CSIRO – wikimedia.org (CC BY 3.0)
CSIRO (the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation), is Australia’s leading science and research agency. It has announced it will cut 350 science research roles across Australia. The government cited rising costs as the organisation faces long-term financial sustainability challenges due to the rising cost of running the science agency, when the government is dealing with imminent budgetary restraints.
CSIRO chief executive, Doug Hilton, said the organisation had to adapt to achieve the right balance of research. “CSIRO’s reason for being is to deliver the greatest possible impact for the nation through our research.” He added, “we have a responsibility to make decisions that ensure we can continue to deliver science that improves the lives of all Australians for generations to come.” Prime Minister, Anthony Albanese said there were more jobs created before this round of redundancies.
The CSIRO estimates it will need to invest up to $135 million each year over the next ten years into essential infrastructure and technology. This includes repairs and maintenance on existing sites, research equipment, cyber protection and technology. Nearly 80 per cent of the CSIRO’s more than 800 buildings are approaching their end-of-life cycles and the agency would need $135 million each year to replace or renovate them.
The cuts announcement was slammed by the CSIRO Staff Association. These “devastating cuts” come on top of the 800 research and science job losses in the past 18 months. Ed Husic oversaw job cuts to CSIRO administration and support teams when he was the science minister in 2024. Now Husic has challenged his own government to “pry open the jaws of Treasury” to boost funding for Australia’s national scientific agency. Husic said that ‘Treasury and finance’ saw CSIRO’s funding as a budget cost, and not an investment in the future. Husic told the ABC, “If you do value science, you need to stop looking at science and research as a cost, and see it as an investment in the future, wellbeing and capability of the country.”
The cuts have been condemned by unions. STA (Science and Technology Australia) CEO Ryan Winn called the job cuts “a step in the wrong direction for Australia’s research system.” Winn added, that CSIRO also needs to invest an additional $80 to $135 million per year, and said that it’s “crucial these facilities receive sustained funding.”
Australian Academy of Technological Sciences & Engineering (ATSE) President Dr Katherine Woodthorpe said, “Australia and the world have greatly benefited from the work that CSIRO has done for more than a century.” Woodthorpe said, “We need long-term planning, strategy and investment for CSIRO … and we need the ongoing financial commitment to match government’s promise of support for science and research.”
Professor Chennupati Jagadish, President of the Australian Academy of Science, said that funding “has gone down during the last 15 years or so. … We need to invest more in R&D and change the direction of this downward slope so that investment is moving in a positive direction. … We also need to ensure that research is seen as an investment, not as a cost.”
Certainly CSIRO inventions and innovations have had an amazing economic impact on Australia and the world. Wi-Fi (Fast Wireless LAN) was invented by CSIRO, adding tens of billions annually (via mobile commerce, teleworking, logistics, IoT) to national productivity. Another major invention is the polymer banknote, with revenues from international licensing at $500 million since the 1990s. CSIRO has improved varieties of wheat, barley, cotton, and canola, an increase of $12 billion in productivity over thirty years. Overall, CSIRO has added $1.1 billion in patent licensing revenue just in Australia.
The invention of ‘gene shears’ (early gene-editing technology) has had a global economic value of billions of dollars in research tools and therapies. Global sales of CSIRO’s patented material Extended-Wear Contact Lenses exceeds $15 billion. There’s also Aerogard insect repellent which generated hundreds of millions of dollars in retail sales in Australia and the Asia-Pacific.
The CSIRO Total Wellbeing Diet has added $10 billion per year to the national economy. Even its Radio Astronomy Technologies have attracted hundreds of millions in international investment into Australian engineering and infrastructure, and the spinoff technologies in signal processing have improved defence and telecommunications industries worth hundreds of millions more.
Overall the government’s cuts are very short-sighted and will directly impact Australia’s important international scientific position. What the CSIRO has done so far has been world-changing.
It’s impossible to list what the CSIRO would do if properly funded, but we can have an idea of the cost. Using the standard economics Present Value of a Growing Annuity Formula gives the worst-case scenario of a 30 per cent cut at $21 billion loss over 10 years. With a modest 5 per cent reduction in CSIRO’s economic contribution gives $3.5 billion in lost economic value over 10 years. These projections show how cumulative lost economic output can add up under plausible assumptions, underlining the importance of the CSIRO’s output.
PM Albanese defended the announcement, saying his government was a “friend of science” compared to the Liberal-National Coalition government led by Abott, Turnbull, and Morrison. It’s true that Labor is not as bad as the Coalition was. Between the 2012-13 and 2015-16 federal budgets, the agency cut 659 staff, leaving a total of 5,056 staff. Under the Albanese government, staffing rose to 6,050 in 2024, before the expected 555-person reduction this year.
Parliamentary library analysis commissioned by ACT Senator, David Pocock, showed that annual funding as a percentage of GDP is now at its lowest since 1978.
The cuts are surprising, as the Labor Party does have a number of scientists amongst its ministers and senators. Julian Hill (MP for Bruce, ALP) holds a Bachelor of Science (Chemistry). Dr Michelle Ananda-Rajah (Senator, ALP) is a medical doctor and researcher holding a PhD. Before politics, she was a clinician-scientist in infectious diseases with many scientific publications.
In defensive mode, PM Albanese said, “we want to make sure that every single dollar of funding for scientific research is going in the right direction.” The Coalition is trying to get mileage out of the cuts, by criticising the choice of areas to cut, but the truth is there’s plenty of blame to go around. Chief Executive Hilton has said that the CSIRO’s funding hasn’t kept pace with inflation under both Coalition and Labor governments. Chronic below-inflation funding, he said, “just doesn’t keep up with the cost of doing science.”
PROFIT AND USE
Profits from the commercialisation of CSIRO inventions stay in Australia. If the research is sent overseas using foreign labs it would mean this economic value is exported. CSIRO also does research which is only possible in Australia. Critical technologies such as biosecurity, environmental monitoring, nuclear technologies, and vaccines require domestic control. If agricultural research is done overseas it would be done within a foreign climate, regulatory system, and market-specific region which would have to be adapted to Australian conditions greatly increasing costs.
PRIORITIES
The negative economic impact of funding cuts will be felt medium-to-long term. The consequences are the reduced capacity to innovate, leading to lower productivity gains. Without reversing the cuts, Australia will weaken its scientific base, which will reduce high-growth, high-value industries such as biotech, clean energy, and advanced manufacturing.
It’s worth comparing CSIRO funding to that of AUKUS. When it comes to science, the Prime Minister talks about making sure that “every single dollar” is going in the right direction.” When it comes to funding nuclear-powered submarines that will work to the USA’s benefit, the Labor government didn’t hesitate to commit to an extra $6 billion on top of $12 billion spent so far to encourage the US to stay the course.
The AUKUS spending will make Australia’s future more dangerous. The CSIRO cuts will sacrifice Australia’s economic and environmental future.
To protest the cuts, contact your ALP Senators and local member. You can also sign the petition at www.proudtobepublic.org.au/csiro or use the QR code below.
